Mark
McClain's Thought Challenge this past Friday about Surveys certainly spurred
responses with this comment received yesterday.
Self-report surveys are usually
used to paint a particular picture – unfortunately not always an accurate
picture. Even Federal Crime Reports, such as the FBI's Uniform Crime Report,
exclude certain crimes and classify other crimes in particular ways. Statistical
data is the most accurate information, but even that can be grouped and skewed
to include certain things and exclude other things. The only accurate way to
gauge companies equally across the board is for the companies to classify and
record the data in the same way and then the survey company go to each company
and data mine and record it themselves. By doing that, there is one entity using
the same metrics to measure everyone under the same standards. Anytime you have
multi-organization collaboration, there is room for differences in the reporting
and recording processes, interpretation of data, and the possibility of
filtering data to create certain profile.
Provided by John Reid
|